Coin shops in Sayville, NY

There is 1 shop in Sayville, New York on CoinShopMap. Of these, none list Sunday hours. Check hours before you go: small shops often close for coin shows.

All coin shops in Sayville

• Park Avenue Rarities

  173 N Main St suite 232

  Closed now · ★ 3.2 (24)

  ANA memberPCGS/NGC submissionsBy appointment only

  Call

More coin shops within 25 miles of Sayville

• Tri-State Assets

  90 Colin Dr, Holbrook, NY · 3.0 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.6 (12)

  Buys coinsBuys gold & silverAppraisalsPCGS/NGC submissionsBy appointment only

  Call

• New York Numismatic Group

  1650 Sycamore Ave, Bohemia, NY · 4.0 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.6 (11)

  Buys coinsBuys whole collections & estatesPaper money

  Call

• Miller's Mint

  313 E Main St, Patchogue, NY · 4.4 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.9 (216)

  Buys coinsBuys gold & silverAppraisalsStampsPaper money

  Call

• Gold Depot

  992 S 2nd St Ste. A, Ronkonkoma, NY · 4.5 mi

  Closed now · ★ 5.0 (3)

  Call

• Premier Coin Galleries

  3240 Sunrise Hwy South Service Rd, East Islip, NY · 5.0 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.0 (118)

  Call

• New York Coin & Bullion

  3240 Sunrise Hwy Ste 100, East Islip, NY · 5.0 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.5 (13)

  Sells bullion

  Call

• Affinity Collectibles

  2805 Veterans Memorial Hwy #17, Ronkonkoma, NY · 5.0 mi

  Closed now · ★ 3.5 (13)

  ANA memberBuys coinsBuys gold & silverSells bullionBuys whole collections & estatesAppraisalsPCGS/NGC submissions

  Call

• Barkley Rarities

  2805 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Ronkonkoma, NY · 5.0 mi

  Closed now · ★ 5.0 (4)

  By appointment only

  Call

• Ronkonkoma Rare Coins & Books

  283 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY · 6.3 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.6 (48)

  Call

• Center Gold II

  1097 Portion Rd, Farmingville, NY · 6.8 mi

  Closed now · ★ 5.0 (82)

  Buys coinsBuys gold & silverSells bullionAppraisals

  Call

• Antiques Estate Buyers

  36 Ocean Ave, Islip, NY · 7.3 mi

  Closed now

  Buys coinsBuys gold & silverBuys whole collections & estatesAppraisals

  Call

• Freeman Coins & Collectibles

  2639-2 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY · 8.5 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.9 (52)

  Buys coinsBuys gold & silverBuys whole collections & estatesAppraisals

  Call

Coin shops in nearby cities

• Holbrook, NY (1 · 3 mi)
• Bohemia, NY (1 · 4 mi)
• Patchogue, NY (1 · 4 mi)
• Ronkonkoma, NY (3 · 5 mi)
• East Islip, NY (2 · 5 mi)
• Lake Ronkonkoma, NY (1 · 6 mi)
• Farmingville, NY (1 · 7 mi)
• Islip, NY (1 · 7 mi)

Sayville coin shop FAQ

How many coin shops are in Sayville, NY?

CoinShopMap lists 1 shop in Sayville, plus 12 shops within 25 miles.

Which Sayville coin shops buy gold and silver?

None of the Sayville shops we list have confirmed they buy gold and silver. Call ahead and ask.

Are any coin shops in Sayville open on Sunday?

None of the Sayville shops we list have Sunday hours.

Last updated October 23, 2026.