Coin shops in Islip, NY

There is 1 shop in Islip, New York on CoinShopMap. Of these, 1 buys gold and silver, 1 does appraisals and 1 opens on Sundays. Check hours before you go: small shops often close for coin shows.

All coin shops in Islip

• Antiques Estate Buyers

  36 Ocean Ave

  Closed now

  Buys coinsBuys gold & silverBuys whole collections & estatesAppraisals

  Call

More coin shops within 25 miles of Islip

• New York Coin & Bullion

  3240 Sunrise Hwy Ste 100, East Islip, NY · 2.7 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.5 (13)

  Sells bullion

  Call

• Premier Coin Galleries

  3240 Sunrise Hwy South Service Rd, East Islip, NY · 2.7 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.0 (118)

  Call

• Affinity Collectibles

  2805 Veterans Memorial Hwy #17, Ronkonkoma, NY · 5.8 mi

  Closed now · ★ 3.5 (13)

  ANA memberBuys coinsBuys gold & silverSells bullionBuys whole collections & estatesAppraisalsPCGS/NGC submissions

  Call

• Barkley Rarities

  2805 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Ronkonkoma, NY · 5.8 mi

  Closed now · ★ 5.0 (4)

  By appointment only

  Call

• Liberty Jewelry & Coin Gallery

  1864 Deer Park Ave, Deer Park, NY · 6.2 mi

  · ★ 4.1 (24)

  Stamps

  Call

• New York Numismatic Group

  1650 Sycamore Ave, Bohemia, NY · 6.4 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.6 (11)

  Buys coinsBuys whole collections & estatesPaper money

  Call

• Park Avenue Rarities

  173 N Main St suite 232, Sayville, NY · 7.3 mi

  Closed now · ★ 3.2 (24)

  ANA memberPCGS/NGC submissionsBy appointment only

  Call

• Gold Depot

  992 S 2nd St Ste. A, Ronkonkoma, NY · 7.5 mi

  Closed now · ★ 5.0 (3)

  Call

• Future Gold Diamonds & Coins

  Jewerly Exchange, 20 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Commack, NY · 8.7 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.3 (6)

  Buys coinsBuys gold & silver

  Call

• Ronkonkoma Rare Coins & Books

  283 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY · 9.3 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.6 (48)

  Call

• Tri-State Assets

  90 Colin Dr, Holbrook, NY · 9.4 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.6 (12)

  Buys coinsBuys gold & silverAppraisalsPCGS/NGC submissionsBy appointment only

  Call

• First Commemorative Mint

  101 Carolyn Blvd B, Farmingdale, NY · 10.6 mi

  Closed now · ★ 3.0 (3)

  Call

Coin shops in nearby cities

• East Islip, NY (2 · 3 mi)
• Deer Park, NY (1 · 6 mi)
• Ronkonkoma, NY (3 · 6 mi)
• Bohemia, NY (1 · 6 mi)
• Sayville, NY (1 · 7 mi)
• Commack, NY (1 · 9 mi)
• Holbrook, NY (1 · 9 mi)
• Lake Ronkonkoma, NY (1 · 9 mi)

Islip coin shop FAQ

How many coin shops are in Islip, NY?

CoinShopMap lists 1 shop in Islip, plus 12 shops within 25 miles.

Which Islip coin shops buy gold and silver?

1 shop in Islip list buying gold and silver. Look for the "Buys gold & silver" badge below, and call ahead to ask how they price against the spot price.

Are any coin shops in Islip open on Sunday?

1 shop in Islip list Sunday hours.

Last updated October 23, 2026.