Coin shops in Oyster Bay, NY

There is 1 shop in Oyster Bay, New York on CoinShopMap. Of these, 1 buys gold and silver, 1 does appraisals and none list Sunday hours. Check hours before you go: small shops often close for coin shows.

All coin shops in Oyster Bay

• Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay

  90 South St

  Closed now · ★ 4.2 (70)

  Buys coinsBuys gold & silverAppraisals

  Call

More coin shops within 25 miles of Oyster Bay

• Legacy Tangible Assets

  125 Michael Dr Ste 105, Syosset, NY · 4.7 mi

  Closed now · ★ 5.0 (14)

  Buys coinsBuys gold & silverSells bullionBuys whole collections & estatesAppraisalsBy appointment only

  Call

• Omega Precious Metals

  30A Glen St, Glen Cove, NY · 5.3 mi

  Temporarily closed

  Call

• Costello's Rare Coins

  187 Park Ave, Halesite, NY · 5.9 mi

  Closed now · ★ 5.0 (9)

  Buys coinsSells bullionBy appointment only

  Call

• Legacy Coins & Capital

  1 Dupont St #100, Plainview, NY · 6.2 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.9 (228)

  Buys gold & silverAppraisalsBy appointment only

  Call

• J & F Coins & Jewelry

  45 Glen Cove Rd Ste 101, Greenvale, NY · 6.6 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.5 (26)

  Buys coinsBuys gold & silverStamps

  Call

• Numismatic Assets

  900 Walt Whitman Rd #105, Melville, NY · 8.1 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.4 (25)

  Call

• Goldfellas

  90 Broadhollow Rd, Melville, NY · 8.2 mi

  Closed now

  ANA memberBuys coinsBuys gold & silverPCGS/NGC submissionsPaper money

  Call

• Huntington Stamp & Coin

  1060 E Jericho Tpke, Huntington, NY · 8.8 mi

  Closed now · ★ 4.0 (28)

  Stamps

  Call

• American Coins & Gold

  207 Old Country Rd, Carle Place, NY · 9.9 mi

  Temporarily closed · ★ 4.7 (134)

  AppraisalsStamps

  Call

• Coin Galleries of Oyster Bay

  3535 Hempstead Tpke, Levittown, NY · 10.2 mi

  Closed now · ★ 2.7 (34)

  Call

• Silvergreetings.Com

  405 RXR Plaza, Uniondale, NY · 10.9 mi

  Closed now · ★ 5.0 (1)

  Call

• American Rarities Rare Coin Company

  405 RXR Plaza, Uniondale, NY · 10.9 mi

  Closed now · ★ 1.0 (1)

  Call

Coin shops in nearby cities

• Syosset, NY (1 · 5 mi)
• Glen Cove, NY (1 · 5 mi)
• Halesite, NY (1 · 6 mi)
• Plainview, NY (1 · 6 mi)
• Greenvale, NY (1 · 7 mi)
• Huntington, NY (1 · 8 mi)
• Melville, NY (2 · 8 mi)
• Carle Place, NY (1 · 10 mi)

Oyster Bay coin shop FAQ

How many coin shops are in Oyster Bay, NY?

CoinShopMap lists 1 shop in Oyster Bay, plus 12 shops within 25 miles.

Which Oyster Bay coin shops buy gold and silver?

1 shop in Oyster Bay list buying gold and silver. Look for the "Buys gold & silver" badge below, and call ahead to ask how they price against the spot price.

Are any coin shops in Oyster Bay open on Sunday?

None of the Oyster Bay shops we list have Sunday hours.

Last updated October 23, 2026.