Coin shops in Middletown, NY

There is 1 shop in Middletown, New York on CoinShopMap. Of these, 1 does appraisals and none list Sunday hours. Check hours before you go: small shops often close for coin shows.

All coin shops in Middletown

• Dart Stamp & Coin Shop

  130 Dolson Ave #3A

  Closed now · ★ 4.7 (82)

  Buys coinsAppraisalsPCGS/NGC submissionsStamps

  Call

Pawn shops and jewelers that also buy coins in Middletown

Not coin shops, so they're not counted above. Useful if you're selling scrap gold or a few common coins; for anything collectible, start with a coin shop.

• Malek Gold Buyers

  Jeweler

  630 NY-211 E

  Closed now · ★ 4.6 (38)

  Buys coinsBuys gold & silverBuys whole collections & estatesAppraisalsCollecting supplies

  Call

Coin shops in nearby cities

• Ramsey, NJ (1 · 30 mi)
• Pompton Lakes, NJ (1 · 31 mi)
• Sparta, NJ (1 · 31 mi)
• Nanuet, NY (1 · 32 mi)
• Wyckoff, NJ (1 · 32 mi)
• Yorktown Heights, NY (1 · 33 mi)
• Waldwick, NJ (1 · 33 mi)
• North Haledon, NJ (1 · 35 mi)

Middletown coin shop FAQ

How many coin shops are in Middletown, NY?

CoinShopMap lists 1 shop in Middletown.

Which Middletown coin shops buy gold and silver?

None of the Middletown shops we list have confirmed they buy gold and silver. Call ahead and ask.

Are any coin shops in Middletown open on Sunday?

None of the Middletown shops we list have Sunday hours.

Last updated October 23, 2026.